Old School Dice vs Gnome Forged Metal Dice: Which Set Fits Your Game?
By Tanuki Games | Published: 2026-10-29
Category: Comparisons
Compare Old School Dice sharp edged resin sets with Gnome Forged metal dice to find the right RPG dice for your table.
Quick Answer
Choose Gnome Forged metal dice if you want a hefty, durable set with a classic metal feel; choose the Sharp Edged resin set if you prefer a lighter, hand-polished look with crisp edges.
Material Matters: Metal vs. Resin
The biggest difference between these two dice sets is the material. Gnome Forged dice are metal, which gives them a satisfying weight and a solid feel in your hand. They are also more durable over time, resisting the wear that softer materials might show.
Old School Dice Sharp Edged sets are made from a handmade and polished resin blend. This makes them noticeably lighter and easier to roll for long sessions. The resin also allows for unique colors and patterns, like the Snowy Mountain design, that metal cannot replicate.
Comfort and Handling
If you play long RPG sessions, weight matters. Metal dice can feel heavy after hours of rolling, and they can be harder on your dice tray or table. Resin dice are gentler and less tiring to handle, but they may not have the same premium heft that some players enjoy.
The Sharp Edged resin dice have crisp, defined edges that look striking on the table. Metal dice, like the Gnome Forged set, often have a more classic, rounded shape that some players prefer for its traditional feel.
Trade-Offs at a Glance
- Weight and Feel: Metal dice feel heavy and premium; resin dice are lighter and easier to roll for hours. Consider your session length and table setup before choosing.
- Durability: Metal is more resistant to wear and scratches; resin can show scuffs over time but is less likely to dent your table. If you play on a hard surface, metal dice may require a dice tray.
- Aesthetics: Metal offers a classic, metallic shine; resin allows for unique patterns and colors like Snowy Mountain. Think about which look matches your character or campaign theme.
Product Facts
- Old School 7 Piece DnD RPG Metal Dice Set: Gnome Forged - Black Nickel w/ Red: Each 7-piece set comes with an exclusive Old School Dice & Accessories Metal Dice Tin, and the dice are forged by Gnome Mastersmiths. You get a sturdy storage tin and a metal set with a distinctive black nickel and red finish that stands out on the table.
Old School 7 Piece DnD RPG Metal Dice Set: Gnome Forged - Black Nickel w/ Red - Old School Dice: Sharp Edged 7-Piece Dice Set - Snowy Mountain: The Sharp Edged dice are a handmade and polished resin blend that look like no other dice you have seen. The resin material gives you a lighter, uniquely patterned set with sharp edges, ideal for players who want a striking look without the weight of metal.
Old School Dice: Sharp Edged 7-Piece Dice Set - Snowy Mountain
Which Set Should You Choose?
Best for
- Players who want a durable, heavy set with a classic metal feel
- Gamers who appreciate a matching storage tin and a traditional look
Not for
- Players who prefer a lighter, easier-to-roll die for long sessions
- Those who want unique color patterns that resin can offer
