Tanuki Games

The Plum Island Horror: More of a Bad Thing Expansion

The Plum Island Horror: More of a Bad Thing Expansion - Main image
$53.92 $74.89 In stock

Category: Board Games

Well, well, well…you just couldn’t get enough of The Plum Island Horror, could you? And now you went and asked for more “stuff.” Well, to quote AC/DC, “if you want blood, you got it.” Despite my better judgment, the GMT bigwigs have harassed, cudgeled, and shamed me into emerging from my quiet, peaceful retirement and designing more pain and agony for you to enjoy. Bang the drums and sound the trumpets! The More of a Bad Thing expansion is here.

And this time, we’re not taking it easy on you. We’ve asked our elite research team to dig even farther into the historic archives regarding this event, and they’ve uncovered some interesting elements to the story of Plum Island that are not included in the original game (P.S. They’ve all since been fired for not uncovering this stuff for the game in the first place).

Review your basket

Check the items, quantities and final amount before paying.

Plan your delivery

Use the delivery estimate when planning when to place your order.

Standard Shipping: Handling (business days) 0–1; Transit (business days) 7–15.

Express Shipping: Handling (business days) 0–1; Transit (business days) 7–15.

View policy
Help with a refund

Have your order number ready when asking the store about a refund.

Please contact us for the refund processing timeframe before returning an item.

View policy
Shipping for your order

Check the charge for the delivery option you choose.

Standard Shipping · United States: $0.00

Express Shipping · United States: $3.99

View policy
Checking return eligibility

Read the return policy for your item before arranging a return.

United States · Return window (days after delivery): 30. Return method: By mail. Return postage: Seller pays.

View policy

Customer Reviews (5.0 / 5 · 3 reviews)

Penelope ★★★★★

The insert for all these new miniatures is a lifesaver, everything has its spot now. I love that the new event cards actually make the chaos feel more strategic instead of just random. It’s a solid expansion if you want to make the base game harder without it feeling unfair.

Eva ★★★★★

The game setup took longer than I expected, but once we started, the new "more of a bad thing" cards added such chaotic tension that my group played for hours. Having a sixth player option really helped include our friend who usually just watches.

Lily Y. ★★★★★

The new monster cards add a genuinely chaotic edge that the base game was missing, and the setup time barely increased. Finally, a reason to revisit Plum Island with fresh terror.